Skip to content
| Starting Lineup | Name | Position | B/T | bWAR/650 | OPS+ | Years Played |
| 1. | Joe DiMaggio | CF | R/R | 6.7 | 155 | 1936-51 |
| 2. | Mickey Mantle | LF (CF/1B/RF) | S/R | 7.3 | 172 | 1951-68 |
| 3. | Babe Ruth | RF (LF/P) | L/L | 10.2 | 209 | 1920-34 |
| 4. | Lou Gehrig | 1B | L/L | 7.7 | 179 | 1923-39 |
| 5. | Alex Rodriguez | 3B (SS) | R/R | 5.5 | 136 | 2004-16 |
| 6. | Don Mattingly | DH (1B) | L/L | 3.6 | 127 | 1982-95 |
| 7. | Yogi Berra | C (LF/RF) | L/R | 4.7 | 125 | 1946-63 |
| 8. | Derek Jeter | SS | R/R | 3.8 | 115 | 1995-2014 |
| 9. | Willie Randolph | 2B | R/R | 4.8 | 105 | 1976-88 |
| | | | | | |
| Bench | | | | | | |
| OF | Bernie Williams | CF | S/R | 3.6 | 125 | 1991-2006 |
| OF | Earle Combs | CF/LF | L/R | 4.3 | 125 | 1924-35 |
| IN | Tony Lazzeri | 2B/3B | R/R | 4.5 | 120 | 1926-37 |
| IN | Phil Rizzuto | SS | R/R | 4.1 | 93 | 1941-56 |
| C | Bill Dickey | C | L/R | 5.2 | 127 | 1928-46 |
| | | | | | |
| Starting Rotation | Name | | B/T | | ERA+ | Years Played |
| 1. | Whitey Ford | | L/L | | 133 | 1950-67 |
| 2. | Lefty Gomez | | L/L | | 125 | 1930-42 |
| 3. | Red Ruffing | | R/R | | 119 | 1930-46 |
| 4. | Ron Guidry | | L/L | | 119 | 1975-88 |
| 5. | Andy Pettitte | | L/L | | 115 | 1995-2003, 07-10, 12-13 |
| | | | | | |
| Bullpen | | | | | | |
| LR | Dave Righetti | | L/L | | 127 | 1979-90 |
| RP | Sparky Lyle | | L/L | | 148 | 1972-78 |
| RP | David Robertson | | R/R | | 154 | 2008-14, 17-18 |
| RP | Dellin Betances | | R/R | | 177 | 2011-19 |
| SU | Rich Gossage | | R/R | | 179 | 1978-83, 89 |
| CL | Mariano Rivera | | R/R | | 205 | 1995-2013 |